Skip to Main Content

Stephen Pruitt on Education Policy

Stephen Pruitt on Education Policy

Stephen Pruitt on Education Policy

Kentucky Education Commissioner Stephen Pruitt discusses his first year in office and what lies ahead for education in Kentucky.
S11 E32 Length 28:02 Premiere: 8.28.16

Education Commissioner Reflects on First Year

With everything on his plate during his first year as Kentucky’s commissioner of education, Stephen Pruitt didn’t expect to be testifying before Congress.

But there he was, giving his thoughts on the federal Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA) to House and Senate committees earlier this summer. Pruitt praised lawmakers for passing the legislation that gives states greater flexibility in measuring student success. He also warned that draft regulations proposed by the U.S. Department of Education to implement ESSA could stifle innovation and jeopardize the authority of states to set their own education policies.

“I couldn’t sit idly by and be quiet about something that I think was going against what the intent of the Every Student Succeeds Act that was passed by Congress was,” Pruitt says. “I felt strongly and still feel strongly that the draft regulations that came out were putting too many shackles on us.”

Pruitt appeared on KET’s One to One to discuss his testimony and the process to create a new accountability system for Kentucky schools.

The commissioner’s path to Congress began earlier this year when he disagreed with federal education officials about how Kentucky should test science students. Pruitt argued that the options the U.S. Department of Education offered would have yielded testing data that lacked integrity and wouldn’t accurately reflect what students had learned.

Pruitt also criticized a mandate to use old accountability data to identify low-performing schools even though those schools would be judged against new accountability standards.

“Pretty much my head exploded at that point because that was not how I read the law,” Pruitt says. He contends conflating two systems like that is “just wrong. You create so much distrust in the system.”

The commissioner voiced his concerns in letter to U.S. Secretary of Education John B. King Jr., and sent copies to Kentucky’s congressional delegation and to Sen. Lamar Alexander (R-TN), the chairman of the Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions.

That landed Pruitt an invitation to Washington to testify. He told lawmakers he appreciated how ESSA would provide state-level educators greater autonomy than the more rigid No Child Left Behind Act of 2002. But he argued that regulations proposed by federal education officials to implement ESSA are too restrictive and complex. He said the draft rules run counter to the spirit of the legislation that Congress passed last December.

“A compliance mentality prevails,” Pruitt told lawmakers. “Instead of assurances, the proposed regulations call for us to provide evidences. The sheer volume of paperwork that is necessary for peer review is overwhelming. And while the peer review process can be helpful, we are concerned that it is subjective. …”

Pruitt also questioned a requirement for a single score to measure a school’s performance. He said that approach has contributed to an unhealthy competition among schools and efforts by adults to “game the system” to create the appearance of improved student performance rather than actual improvement. (Watch Pruitt’s full testimony to the House Committee on Education and the Workforce in June.)

The commissioner followed up his official testimony with a call to teachers and education stakeholders in the commonwealth to send their own feedback about the ESSA draft rules to federal regulators. He hoped a thousand such comments would be submitted by August 1. Pruitt says he was copied on some of the emails and was pleased with the detailed feedback Kentuckians offered.

A New Approach to Accountability
The final federal ESSA regulations won’t be released until December, but Pruitt isn’t waiting to begin work on a new accountability system for Kentucky. The commissioner held 11 public forums around the state to gather input from educators, parents, and community leaders on how school and student performance should be measured. Pruitt says more than 3,000 people attended those meetings.

“They really want a focus on the whole student,” Pruitt says. “Not just their math and reading scores, but also how can we ensure that they’re having a well rounded education with visual and performing arts, with health and physical education, [and] are we really paying attention to the social welfare of kids.”

A steering committee and five working groups comprised of 168 people are already at work on developing a new accountability platform for the state. Pruitt says although many people use assessments and accountability interchangeably, they’re actually separate issues. He says testing is only one part of accountability. He wants a new system that moves beyond just test scores to something that better guarantees every child receives a quality public education and is prepared for life in the current economy.

Kentucky still faces several significant hurdles to reaching that goal. Recent reports showed that almost 60 percent of recent high school graduates failed to meet the state’s math standard for the ACT college entrance exam. Many poor and minority students experience dramatic achievement gaps compared to their white peers. And Pruitt says the low number of African-American students taking advanced placement classes is “embarrassing.”

Funding is another obstacle for K-12 public education in Kentucky. Pruitt says he’s grateful state legislators maintained basic school funding called SEEK for the next biennium. But he adds that keeping education appropriations the same in an era of escalating costs forces teachers and administrators to do more with what, in reality, is a shrinking pool of dollars.

Despite these challenges, Pruitt says he hopes to have a draft of a new accountability system ready to unveil to the public in November. Then it will go to lawmakers in January when the new legislative session begins. As those discussions unfold, Pruitt says he hopes everyone remembers that the goal is to create a coherent system that provides young people the educational foundation they need.

“Regardless of politics at the end of the day, if it’s about students, let’s all come together and figure out the best way to do it,” Pruitt says. “And as I like to say, if everybody leaves a little bit mad, then you’ve hit it about right.”

Program Details

One to One

About One to One

Host Bill Goodman and a variety of interesting and engaging people talk about the state and world we live in. Important, memorable, and provocative, this series offers an array of interviews with guests including politicians and philosophers, artists and authors, and the leading thinkers in Kentucky.

TV Schedules

Upcoming

No upcoming airdates

Recent

No recent airdates

Season 11

Mitch McConnell on Politics

S11 E49 Length 28:04 Premiere Date 12.19.16

Speaker-Elect Jeff Hoover

S11 E48 Length 28:01 Premiere Date 12.19.16

Kentucky Harm Reduction Coalition

S11 E46 Length 28:21 Premiere Date 12.18.16

Former Congressman Barney Frank

S11 E45 Length 28:36 Premiere Date 12.11.16

Kentucky Youth Advocates

S11 E44 Length 29:02 Premiere Date 11.20.16

Ramez Naam and Seth Siegel

S11 E43 Length 27:31 Premiere Date 11.13.16

Former U.S. Sen. Tom Daschle

S11 E42 Length 27:35 Premiere Date 11.6.16

Kentucky Book Fair Preview

S11 E41 Length 28:02 Premiere Date 10.30.16

U.S. Sen Rand Paul

S11 E40 Length 28:02 Premiere Date 10.23.16

Lexington Mayor Jim Gray

S11 E39 Length 28:02 Premiere Date 10.16.16

U.S. Rep. Andy Barr

S11 E38 Length 28:00 Premiere Date 10.9.16

Nancy Jo Kemper

S11 E37 Length 27:46 Premiere Date 10.2.16

Gary Gregg; Daniel Hayes

S11 E36 Length 28:02 Premiere Date 9.25.16

Adam Edelen and Matt Jones

S11 E35 Length 27:51 Premiere Date 9.17.16

Ky. Labor Secretary Derrick Ramsey

S11 E34 Length 28:01 Premiere Date 9.11.16

Stephen Pruitt on Education Policy

S11 E32 Length 28:02 Premiere Date 8.28.16

Work Ready Skills Initiative

S11 E31 Length 27:52 Premiere Date 8.21.16

Mary Matalin and James Carville

S11 E30 Length 27:18 Premiere Date 8.14.16

BBC Anchor Katty Kay

S11 E29 Length 29:02 Premiere Date 8.7.16

Fancy Farm 2016 Preview

S11 E28 Length 28:36 Premiere Date 7.31.16

Kentucky's Open Records Law

S11 E27 Length 27:51 Premiere Date 7.24.16

Kentucky's Medicaid Waiver

S11 E26 Length 28:16 Premiere Date 7.17.16

The Future of Agribusiness

S11 E25 Length 27:32 Premiere Date 7.9.16

Sen. Mitch McConnell's Memoir

S11 E24 Length 29:46 Premiere Date 7.3.16

Oral Health Integration

S11 E23 Length 28:42 Premiere Date 6.19.16

Apple Co-Founder Steve Wozniak

S11 E22 Length 28:26 Premiere Date 6.12.16

Pearse Lyons and Family

S11 E21 Length 28:51 Premiere Date 6.5.16

"Dreamland" Author Sam Quinones

S11 E20 Length 29:31 Premiere Date 5.29.16

Rethinking Pain Treatment

S11 E19 Length 27:11 Premiere Date 5.22.16

Drug Czar Michael Botticelli

S11 E18 Length 29:01 Premiere Date 5.15.16

Drug Addiction and the Brain

S11 E17 Length 27:41 Premiere Date 5.8.16

Kentucky's Opioid Abuse Epidemic

S11 E16 Length 29:01 Premiere Date 5.1.16

David Adkisson and Jason Bailey

S11 E15 Length 28:16 Premiere Date 4.24.16

Ben Chandler on Baseball and Family

S11 E14 Length 27:47 Premiere Date 4.17.16

Highlights from the Rx Drug Abuse and Heroin Summit

S11 E13 Length 29:06 Premiere Date 4.10.16

Allison Ball and Ryan Quarles

S11 E12 Length 28:16 Premiere Date 4.2.16

Author Fenton Johnson

S11 E11 Length 27:31 Premiere Date 3.27.16

Rep. Sannie Overly

S11 E9 Length 28:06 Premiere Date 2.28.16

Kentucky's Republican Presidential Caucus

S11 E8 Length 27:51 Premiere Date 2.21.16

Education Secretary Hal Heiner

S11 E7 Length 28:01 Premiere Date 2.14.16

Presidential Politics in Kentucky

S11 E6 Length 28:01 Premiere Date 2.7.16

Gov. Bevin on Budget Proposals

S11 E5 Length 27:31 Premiere Date 1.29.16

Postsecondary Education Funding

S11 E4 Length 28:02 Premiere Date 1.24.16

House Speaker Greg Stumbo

S11 E3 Length 28:01 Premiere Date 1.17.16

Mitch McConnell on 2016

S11 E2 Length 28:31 Premiere Date 1.10.16

Senate President Robert Stivers

S11 E1 Length 28:02 Premiere Date 1.3.16

Explore KET